Is a fractional executive worth it for your company? It can be, as long as you know what you are buying. A fractional CFO, COO, or CMO is an experienced executive who works with your leadership team on strategy and brings an outside perspective. This episode is for owners who need executive-level help but can’t yet justify a full-time salary, and for anyone who has hired a fractional executive and wasn’t sure what they were supposed to be getting.
Jeff Robertson, Greg Gorman, and Katherine Cooper have each worked as fractional executives in different departments, and in this episode they talk with Adam Cooper about what that looks like in practice. They start with the question clients ask first, which is how many hours they will get, and explain why a good agreement spells out the meetings and face time while the work itself takes whatever it takes. Greg explains the difference between a controller, who reports on what already happened, and a CFO, who plans where the business is going. Jeff explains why a COO has to understand the whole business, not only what happens in the field. Katherine explains what a fractional CMO adds beyond a marketing agency: a strategy across all of your channels instead of more of what is already working. They also cover how an engagement should end, either by helping onboard the full-time executive you hire or by leaving your team able to run without outside help.
What’s in this episode
- How many hours you get, and why a good agreement spells out the meetings and face time while the work takes whatever it takes
- The difference between a controller, who reports on what already happened, and a CFO, who plans where the business is going
- Why a fractional COO has to understand the whole business, not only what happens in the field
- What a fractional CMO adds beyond a marketing agency: a strategy across all of your channels instead of more of what is already working
- How an engagement should end: helping onboard the full-time executive you hire, or leaving your team able to run without outside help
Timestamps
00:00 Cold open and welcome
00:56 Fractional versus interim executives
02:59 “How many hours do I get?”
04:41 Adam’s first fractional engagement and setting expectations
07:51 What to expect from a fractional CFO
11:07 What a fractional COO covers
14:22 What a fractional CMO adds
19:52 The “easy button” myth
21:23 Doer or overseer: start with the outcome
22:31 How a fractional engagement should end
26:00 Is a fractional executive right for your company?
26:45 Controller versus CFO
27:50 What a fractional COO needs to know
29:03 Marketing agency versus CMO
33:20 Fractional, but still an executive
36:20 Business coach versus fractional executive
38:44 The pinch hitter
Need Executive-Level Help Without a Full-Time Salary?
If you need executive-level help in finance, operations, or marketing but can’t yet justify a full-time salary, Ascent Consulting’s Fractional CFO, Fractional COO, and Fractional CMO engagements start with the outcome you need and a clear scope to get there.
Transcript
[00:00] Katherine Cooper: I can absolutely wave my magic wand and fix all your ***, but that’s not the price of $7,000 a month. That’s all the money.
[00:13] Adam Cooper: Well, welcome to today’s episode of Construction Hot Takes. Today we’re going to talk about fractional executives. We have all served as fractional executives for clients over the last four or five years: fractional CFO, fractional COO, fractional CMO, some combination of all of those. We’ve all served in these fractional executive roles. And we get a lot of questions about these. We get a lot of interest. I think it would be good to start by talking about what a fractional executive is, as opposed to, say, an interim executive. That’s a distinction that a lot of times our clients aren’t quite as familiar with. They don’t understand the difference between fractional and interim. So maybe that’s a good way to start the conversation off.
[00:56] Katherine Cooper: Yeah, I’d say the conversation that kicked off this whole episode was we were doing a debrief of one of Jeff’s projects that happened to be a fractional executive role, and I kind of brought up that I’ve been seeing a similar issue, and then we looped Greg in and said, “Do you see this too?” And it’s like, do people know what they’re buying when they say, “I want a fractional whatever,” insert option? And we think the answer is no.
[01:18] Greg Gorman: Well, I’ll add that prior to coming to Ascent, I worked at an interim firm. So I’ve always been really keyed in on this, because when someone calls an interim firm, that’s what they think you are: “We’re going to hire you almost like a staffing company. We’re going to hire you full-time. You’re going to come to our office and you’re going to work for us for six months or 12 months or whatever.” So, we do not do that at Ascent. We are what is called fractional. And so I’m keyed into it, because I can explain to people what the difference is. Sometimes it’s pretty obvious by how they ask their questions, but sometimes it’s not obvious.
[01:58] Jeff Robertson: That’s the problem. Well, you hit the nail on the head. The interim is you’re a full-time employee, maybe a staff extension, if you will, for a period of time. It could be a couple months. It could be a couple years, to fill a vacancy, maybe while they do an executive search for a full-time employee, or contract for hire,
[02:17] Adam Cooper: Right.
[02:17] Jeff Robertson: employee in that role. But it’s a full-time job for you.
[02:21] Jeff Robertson: Or there’s a special project, which is another thing, like you’re hiring someone to come in and do, let’s say, a new software is going to come in and you’re going to be there for two years, and that is your job there, right? You don’t have to do everything else. You just have to do that. So, there’s reasons that people bring in full-time interim staff members.
[02:40] Jeff Robertson: I think the challenge that I’ve seen is that I think people conceptually understand the difference. There’s an affordability function there: “I don’t want to hire someone full-time. I want somebody…”
[02:53] Katherine Cooper: “I don’t have enough work to keep a CFO busy all the time. I need somebody for 10 to 20 hours a week.”
[02:59] Jeff Robertson: Right.
[02:59] Jeff Robertson: Well, that’s what I was getting at: “I don’t need someone full-time.” But then there becomes this conversation around, “Well, how many hours are you going to dedicate to me? When I get you, how much do I get of you?” Right? And how do we define that? And we don’t think like that, actually, or I don’t. When I do my fractional engagements, it’s not, “Well, you get me for 10 hours a month.” And actually, I had this question yesterday. It was that almost exact scenario. And I said, “Well, if we spent 10 hours together over the first two days of a month and you called me on the third day and really want to talk, I’m not going to tell you, ‘Well, I’ll see you in 28 days.’ We’ll talk about it.” We don’t put a limit on that.
[03:41] Adam Cooper: Well, and sometimes it’s easy. I’ve had a few calls in the last month where people have said, “All right, I’m looking for a fractional COO,” is what these two were, “so when can you get onto my job site, and when can you start working?” And that’s a pretty telltale sign. They’re looking for someone to really fly in, be in the trailer, be there every day, and kind of take over. And so that’s when it’s easy to tell them what the difference is. It’s when they don’t know yet that I think we can help them.
[04:08] Jeff Robertson: Well, and that’s fair, too, because there’s a long tradition, especially in construction, of project executives and operations managers that are either approaching or retired, and they say, “Well, I’m not really ready to stop working, so I’m going to be a consultant.” And what that means is they go to work as what they were doing before, just a gun for hire, part-time. And they get to pick and choose their clients and so on, but they’re basically just a gun for hire on a project or projects, which, again, is not what we do.
[04:41] Adam Cooper: So the first fractional engagement that I got was years ago. It was one of my clients back in, call it, 2016, 2017. They needed a fractional COO, and what they really needed was a full-time CFO, but they didn’t have anybody. So they were going on an executive search for six months. So they engaged me to be a fractional COO. They really wanted an interim. I didn’t have enough time because I had other clients. So what we worked out was that one week I would be in their offices, I think it was in Connecticut, or I’d be on their job sites or whatever it was. And the second week I would be remote. I would be working with other clients, and I’d be available to answer emails and go to a couple of virtual meetings. But it was a lot of time. This is probably 30 to 40 hours, at least, on average, over a two-week span.
[05:41] Katherine Cooper: That’s not scalable. And does that even save the client money? Like an interim, you’re paying a real salary, aren’t you?
[05:44] Adam Cooper: It didn’t. They were paying me as much as, if not more than, what they would have paid a full-time person. But there was an opportunity cost that was factored in. They thought it was going to be for a short term. I set it up so that if they made a hire, I would then help onboard and train that new hire, and then I would step out. And I figured two to four weeks to do an onboarding.
[06:07] Katherine Cooper: Right?
[06:07] Adam Cooper: Eventually it ran its course. They did not find somebody in that window, and I couldn’t continue to support them with that kind of time. So, it ended. That taught me a lot about these engagements, and it taught me that I have to really set some expectations up front, right? Like, I am a fractional. What are the things you need me to work on? And then I can get that done for you on my own time, plus we need to meet every week for two to four hours. And that established how much face time they were getting of me. But I also had things I was doing on that project to help them. If it was a fractional CMO role or a fractional CFO, I was doing analysis. I was running reports on my own time for them. They were only seeing the face time, and that was what was built into the contract: how much face time they got from me. But the scope of work was still the scope of work, and it took whatever hours it took to get that work done.
[07:03] Greg Gorman: I think that’s an important point: one of the things that we can do with our clients is make sure they understand what they are getting and what they are not getting, which is important too, right?
[07:18] Adam Cooper: They should understand this not just from us but any time they’re hiring a fractional.
[07:22] Greg Gorman: That’s what I’m saying. I’ve been on several calls where, at the end of the call, let’s say it was an interim they were looking for and they called us not knowing, and I’ve had several people tell me, “Thank you for telling me that. I didn’t have that vocabulary. I didn’t know they were called interim in the market,” or “I didn’t know that’s what a fractional person does.” I think it’s helpful to have the right vocabulary to understand what you’re getting and to understand what you need them for,
[07:46] Adam Cooper: Yeah.
[07:46] Greg Gorman: as opposed to just thinking that you just want to bring someone in to
[07:50] Adam Cooper: Yeah.
[07:50] Greg Gorman: work on one thing.
[07:51] Adam Cooper: Well, that’s a great segue. So, the next thing would be: what do they actually need? What does a fractional do that, say, an interim doesn’t do, or vice versa, or full-time, like hiring somebody? What does full-time do, versus what should they expect when they’re getting a fractional executive? So, if they’re getting a fractional CFO or a fractional COO or a fractional chief marketing officer, we’re not actually running the business. We’re fractional. We’re there to do a very specific set of actions or produce very specific outputs for them. So, let’s talk. Greg, maybe you should go first as a fractional CFO, because that’s what the majority of your engagements have been. What should they typically expect from a fractional CFO?
[08:39] Greg Gorman: So, I’ll speak just about CFO, because that’s what I know, right? I think there are three things that you can generally expect to get from a fractional CFO. I think the first one is strategy. That’s a broad term, but you bring a fractional CFO in who’s going to help you look at your business on a strategic basis, across the whole business. You don’t have to focus on anything, but what’s the strategy for what you’re doing, what you want to do, what you’re thinking about doing? That’s what a fractional CFO is good at. There are deliverables, too, though. So this is not theoretical. There can be reporting, there can be fixing reporting. So in our world, let’s say the WIP that they’re using is not very detailed, or it’s not good enough for what they need it for. You can come in as a fractional CFO and you can help build a new WIP, and you can roll it out, and you can make sure it’s accurate, and you can leave it with them at the end of the engagement. You now have a functioning WIP that you can use, and the people who produce that are trained up and understand how to use it. And once you leave, the WIP will live on after you and will continue to give the data that you helped set up.
[09:46] Adam Cooper: I think one that I heard about recently was helping a client get converted into percentage of completion
[09:56] Greg Gorman: Yeah, exactly.
[09:57] Adam Cooper: accounting. They weren’t doing POC beforehand. They brought in a fractional CFO for four to six months, worked with them to convert them over to percentage of completion, and then that engagement was ended, because then the controller was able to take it and run with it after that.
[10:13] Greg Gorman: And that’s kind of the third thing. So the third thing is you get experience, and you get review and oversight. Those two things are kind of the same thing. You bring in a fractional CFO because there is expertise there in your business. So I would not necessarily recommend you hire a fractional CFO from one industry to come work for your business. You’re bringing in someone who has done that job, or who has done the job of the people they’re overseeing. They can look at reports. They can look at output. They can look at the monthly financials, and they can say, “Yes, this looks good,” or “This doesn’t look good.” And so you’re buying expertise in a smaller batch.
[10:51] Adam Cooper: Right. Like, a CFO from manufacturing wouldn’t be a good fit to be a fractional CFO in construction, because they’re very different business types, and the accounting is done differently.
[11:00] Greg Gorman: Done differently. You want to get a fractional CFO who comes from the same industry as you.
[11:06] Adam Cooper: It’s great.
[11:06] Greg Gorman: That’s right.
[11:07] Adam Cooper: Jeff, maybe you could talk about a fractional COO engagement you had recently and what that scope looked like, what the benefit was to the client, what they needed you to do.
[11:18] Jeff Robertson: Well, I’ll talk about that kind of generically, I think, in that it’s not unlike the CFO thing. It does kind of depend on what the client needs, but a fractional COO, well, it’s operations focused, so it could cover a lot of different ground. And I find that it actually sometimes crosses over into what people might consider CFO territory. Let’s just say, for example, you discover as part of figuring out where your priorities are that your operations team maybe isn’t as involved in AP as it ought to be. Well, that feels like an accounting thing, but it’s really an operations thing as well: making sure the project managers understand, senior project managers, however that’s structured, helping them get a process set up, say, for example, for approving and reviewing invoices at the field side. It could also touch into estimating a little bit, to go win the work. Are we setting ourselves up to win and profit? Is the estimating set up to align with the way we think about how we’re going to build it? So it can cover a very wide range.
[12:36] Adam Cooper: I remember when I was doing some fractional COO work, they used to bring me along as part of their leadership team to interviews on projects, when they were competitive bidding and they were shortlisted. They would bring me in as a subject matter expert as part of their team, because I had a lot of industry experience, say, in multifamily. So I built out their resume for multifamily. So I was there to help them win more work in that respect, just my experience on the team, and then knowing that I would be operationally involved, even if it was only on a part-time basis, with oversight of that team that was delivering that project.
[13:11] Jeff Robertson: I’ve had fractional COO engagements where it was very narrowly focused, but it was about project management skill sets: reading the contract, understanding the contract, understanding the real role of a project manager or the team of project managers, where a project manager stops and the superintendent starts. Like I said, it can cover a really broad range of things.
[13:43] Adam Cooper: Have they ever engaged you on say safety or quality as a COO?
[13:48] Jeff Robertson: Yeah, actually, yes. I’m actually quite passionate about safety. We’ve talked about that quite a bit. We are well aware, and quality as well. They’re two very similar things. They kind of walk and talk the same way. But yeah, we’ve absolutely gotten involved in helping somebody build out a quality program, for example. On the safety side of things, I don’t typically get into helping them build a safety plan. That’s not really where we
[14:15] Jeff Robertson: cultural, like leading, a cultural action role, helping to drive that into the culture.
[14:20] Jeff Robertson: Absolutely. Yes.
[14:22] Adam Cooper: Katherine, fractional CMO, we’ve both done this work as well. I’d love to hear your thoughts. I know you’ve done a few of these in the last couple of years. Talk about what they can expect from a fractional CMO.
[14:33] Katherine Cooper: Yes. Sorry, I’m laughing at myself because I’m over here yawning while Jeff’s talking about safety. I didn’t mean for that to go inside.
[14:39] Adam Cooper: It’s okay. We’ll make sure we get a closeup.
[14:42] Greg Gorman: Everybody in operations knows it’s boring. Maybe we’re going to do a little flashback when they edit it, to show you yawning while Jeff says safety.
[14:52] Katherine Cooper: I was trying to be polite.
[14:53] Adam Cooper: Slow motion, even.
[14:55] Greg Gorman: A split screen of…
[14:57] Katherine Cooper: Yeah.
[14:58] Katherine Cooper: Well, yes. So, the marketing person, whose world is so much more exciting than safety. My fractional CMO clients, I think, came to me almost really misunderstanding what they needed, and through many of those engagements it shifted into they actually ended up hiring our full team to do marketing work. I think, unlike the other roles that we do for fractional, the marketing one is the one where people don’t have the department needed, right? A construction company, a home builder, or a commercial construction company is going to have an accounting person or department. They’re going to have an operations team that’s doing the work. More often than not, they don’t have a marketing team. They may have a person. They may have somebody who does BD and marketing.
[15:58] Greg Gorman: Maybe a part-time job for the office administrator.
[16:02] Katherine Cooper: Their office manager. Exactly.
[16:04] Adam Cooper: Is business development the same as marketing?
[16:07] Katherine Cooper: Same, but different. Or the owner is managing the marketing with a contractor. He’s hired a marketing company, but he’s not a marketing person, or she. We step into that a lot. And they say, “I’m spending money on marketing, but I don’t really know what it’s doing,” or “I’m not getting the results out,” or “We’re doing fine, so something must be working, but I have no idea what it is, and I have no idea if what I’m spending money on is actually what’s driving those results, and I don’t know how to interpret all of the marketing jargon that they’re slinging at me every week and understand how to make a wise decision.” Right?
[16:41] Greg Gorman: Or I’ve seen people use, I don’t know if it’s called this, external marketing, like they’re buying their own ads or they’re doing it themselves the way they think they should. But what a fractional person like you can do is come in and work directly for them on their business, right?
[16:59] Katherine Cooper: Yeah.
[16:59] Greg Gorman: Give them insight from the market, as opposed to them just trying to figure it out themselves.
[17:03] Katherine Cooper: Absolutely. I think that’s the best and highest use of a CMO, especially in construction. I end up in luxury high-end resi work a lot, but I’ve also got some specialty contractors as well. I think that’s really where this works out. But it’s someone who knows what the heck they’re doing, because if you’re an owner of a construction company, you’re probably not a world-class marketer. They usually don’t go hand in hand. So, you need somebody who really knows what they’re talking about to run your team, whether that’s an in-house team, or to build your in-house team, or to tell you who to go hire and place the right people in your team, and/or manage your agency, as the person who can speak and liaise with that world and know that you’re getting what you’re paying for and hold them to account. So, that’s a great role for a CMO. Also, I have a client recently that’s like, “Okay, so we’re doing fine over here, but we want to grow this side of the business, and we have no idea how to do that. Build a plan. Tell me what to do. Tell me who needs to do what.” And so, I think when people come to us saying, “I think I need a fractional CMO,” oftentimes they’re just looking for someone to wave a magic wand and fix the marketing and handle it. And so that’s where I often have to educate in the sales process and really clarify. And I think this really does fit all of these roles: clarify what I can do and what I can’t do, what you could expect from me and not. And yes, I can actually do all of that. I can absolutely wave my magic wand and fix all your ***, but that’s not the price of $7,000 a month. That’s all the money.
[18:44] Adam Cooper: Well, the fractional CMO was knowing how to fix it, not necessarily doing the actual fixing. One of my early CMO roles that I took on was for a builder in San Diego. He had a marketing agency, and they had been performing and working for him for years. And he was a very astute marketer, the owner of the company, but things had stalled and he needed fresh eyes. The marketing company didn’t know what else to do. He didn’t want to just continue to spend more on ads that weren’t performing, and he wanted fresh eyes on it. So they hired me as a fractional CMO, and now I was working with the owner and the marketing agency. We were creative brainstorming. Then the marketing agency would go execute on the strategy that we developed. I was reviewing content. I was reviewing ad strategy, ad spend. I was just looking at everything and helping to steer the ship as an objective third party. I wasn’t the owner, who was personally involved, and I wasn’t the marketing agency that was getting paid either way to do the work and had just run out of ideas. So, I was being paid as a fractional to help critique, provide ideas, measure reporting, help steer that ship.
[19:52] Jeff Robertson: Well, that brings up a really interesting point, because I’d said something when we were doing our debrief. I think there’s this idea out there, at least this is my opinion, or what I think I’ve observed, that any kind of a fractional role, and especially the CFO, feels like this magical wizardry.
[20:15] Katherine Cooper: Oh, you’re supposed to be the easy button.
[20:17] Jeff Robertson: Yeah, you’re supposed to be the easy button: “I’m going to hire a fractional executive, whether it be marketing or operations or whatever.”
[20:23] Katherine Cooper: And like, “Well, you’re just going to…”
[20:25] Adam Cooper: “You’re just going to fix it. Fix everything.”
[20:27] Katherine Cooper: “Just fix it. Just do that.”
[20:29] Greg Gorman: “You know what you’re doing.”
[20:29] Jeff Robertson: And it doesn’t work like that. First off, you can fix a lot of things, but it’s not this mystical kind of thing where somebody shows up with a wizard hat and waves their wand. It just doesn’t work like that. But the outside perspective is what I think is really important. Where I was headed with this is that you’re coming from the outside. You see the business from fresh eyes. Maybe the business owner has a really good idea about something, like your example, but they need another perspective. Sometimes they don’t know what they don’t know. They know what they don’t know, but they don’t really know what to ask for. So that’s when that magical “come in and just do it, fix it” happens: “My CFO is going to fix everything. I can’t read a P&L,” for example. Or “Everybody keeps telling me we need to go get on percentage of completion. Can you come in and just make that happen? Get us on percentage of completion.” It’s not an overnight thing.
[21:21] Greg Gorman: Well, it’s a process.
[21:23] Greg Gorman: So, I think it’s an important point here. I think there’s a line down the middle of a fractional engagement, too, and you both just touched on it. What are you there to do is kind of the question, right? What’s the point of bringing somebody in? Are you a doer? Are you there to do something and fix something and then you’re done? Or are you there to oversee things and help them, right? Sometimes it’s leadership and education, right? So, I think it’s really important going into a fractional engagement, from our point of view as well, but from a client’s point of view: what do I want this engagement to be?
[21:58] Adam Cooper: What’s the outcome I’m trying to get?
[22:00] Greg Gorman: What’s the outcome? What am I going to have at the end? Am I going to have the magic wand thing, and is everything going to be magically fixed? Or am I going to ask this person to come in and focus on one thing and change us from this to this, and that’s it, right? That’s the engagement. And it matters, because in a fractional engagement you can be that specific. You can say, “I want you to work on these three things, and when you leave here in six months, and you’ve spent your 10 hours a week here or whatever, those things will be done.”
[22:31] Katherine Cooper: Yeah. I think it’s an interesting point to consider, at least in marketing. For me, I would say that the most I would ever want to spend in a fractional engagement with a client is probably a year, because either way something else needs to happen after that year, right? They will have, I will have, learned, they will have learned
[22:54] Jeff Robertson: Yeah, the business has evolved.
[22:55] Katherine Cooper: what they need to do, where they need to go, and what the next steps are. And yes, there’s probably lots of objectives that have been completed. But if I’m doing my job well, at the end of a year of a fractional engagement, my client has a couple of different scenarios, right? They either have found the team and built it and know how to run it internally, and maybe they’re on some sort of lower retainer package with me, so they can call me and pick up the phone to say, “Hey, there’s this thing. I had no idea what to say. Can you give me some guidance or send me an email?” Right? That’s still successful. Or I have actually transitioned them to having a third-party partner agency, which we have in house, so ideally they come and be one of our clients, so that my team is still managing all their stuff, and then they do get some guidance from me. And/or they’ve learned what they need to learn. They’ve taken the business where they need to go, and they feel really comfortable running the ship without me. That, to me, is a successful job, and not just keeping me on forever and ever.
[23:53] Adam Cooper: Yeah. Or they’ve now found a full-time person,
[23:57] Katherine Cooper: Found a full-time CMO. Yeah.
[23:58] Adam Cooper: to fully step into that role full time,
[24:00] Katherine Cooper: and maybe I’ve held that person’s hand for several months, and now they can… Like, you’ve done that on the CFO side.
[24:04] Greg Gorman: Well, I was going to say that that is very common in the fractional CFO world. You can be engaged, and it can be both things. It can be back to what I said before. You can be engaged in the beginning. Let’s say, take your example of 12 months. If we use that as a timeline, the first three months are kind of fixing things, and maybe just trying to evaluate things and look at things. Maybe the next three months are actually creating some new things. So, there’s output. But the last six months could be, and I’ve done this, you go as part of the executive search, and you’re on the committee to help find a replacement, and then you hold their hand for three of those months. I mean, it’s all about the scope of the project, I think, is what you’re saying.
[24:43] Adam Cooper: Yeah. What’s the goal at the end of the day?
[24:45] Katherine Cooper: I think that’s what our clients need to consider, or anybody who’s considering hiring a fractional executive should most importantly consider first, before you’re picking up the phone: what do I want to get out of this?
[24:57] Greg Gorman: Right.
[24:58] Katherine Cooper: It should always come back to what the business outcome is that I’m trying to get to, whatever that looks like, even if it’s that I need a full-time person in this seat, and I can’t find one right now, and I need somebody to sit in that seat at least part-time while I do the search and then help onboard that full-time hire. Or, “I don’t know what I don’t know, and I want the end of this agreement to be like, I know what I need to know now.”
[25:19] Adam Cooper: Yes. “I want this skill personally or in-house, and I need to bring in an expert to train, to learn, and to teach us.” Or, back to the earlier example, what we said about being a COO: if you know at the beginning that someone’s looking for someone to go sit on a job site and run a project, if you know that at the beginning, then you know that that’s not what you’re going to get. So, don’t go down that road. Go hire, right, a full-time project manager, or go hire a superintendent on an interim basis, and hire them to run that project for you as a one-off. And that’s perfectly acceptable, too. But you have to almost start at the end
[25:58] Greg Gorman: Yeah.
[25:58] Adam Cooper: when it comes to fractional work.
[26:00] Adam Cooper: All right. Well, how do we wrap this conversation up?
[26:02] Katherine Cooper: Well, I think a good question to ask is how to know if a fractional executive is right for your company. What are some questions? And let’s go by each type, right? How to know if a COO or a CFO or a CMO is right for your company.
[26:16] Adam Cooper: Yeah. I mean, the first one that jumps out at me is either I can’t afford a full-time one. Like, a CFO might be $200,000, and you don’t want to hire them because you don’t have $200,000 to pay for a full-time CFO, or you don’t have a big enough business or a complicated enough business to keep them busy for 40 hours a week. So, it’s a part-time job for somebody. That’s probably the first indicator of where they need somebody fractional, as opposed to a full-time hire or an interim.
[26:45] Greg Gorman: I would say from a fractional CFO point of view, one of the things I see a lot is you hire a fractional CFO because you need a controller, and we’ve talked about this in the past, right? What does that mean? A controller is someone who does your day-to-day accounting. And I use this example a lot. A controller looks backwards. What’s happened? What got paid? What got billed? Where are you in your financial statements? A CFO looks forward. What are we going to build? What are we going to look like in a year? What’s our strategy for growth? So, if you need a controller to do your day-to-day, then you don’t need a fractional CFO. Those are different skills, different experiences, and different outcomes. So, I think it’s important to know what you don’t need as well. That’s kind of what we’re saying.
[27:34] Adam Cooper: Yeah.
[27:34] Jeff Robertson: Yeah. I guess it’s my turn now, right?
[27:36] Katherine Cooper: I just realized we’re all staring at you for a reason.
[27:39] Jeff Robertson: No, I was just enjoying listening to you, and I realized, oh crap, you stopped talking.
[27:44] Greg Gorman: I love that you love hearing about
[27:46] Jeff Robertson: I was really enthralled. I was like, this is great.
[27:48] Katherine Cooper: Construction accounting, Jeff.
[27:50] Jeff Robertson: From an operations standpoint, thinking about the types of challenges that I hear on calls or with clients, and to know what you’re looking for, I would humbly say I have 30-plus years of experience in this business building things, literally being on job sites, running teams, building things. If you’re looking for somebody that’s a fractional COO, I think you need somebody with that kind of a broad understanding of the complete business. How does a dollar or information run all the way through the business? Not just at the field level, but what does it do to the business itself? How does it roll up? Even if you are focused at the field level and trying to help the reporting or operations run well, understanding how that impacts the larger business, and what’s the boss thinking about right now? I think you have to have that really broad understanding. If you’ve just been a project manager, and you’ve never actually run a business, that’s not what a fractional COO does.
[29:01] Adam Cooper: That’s a project executive for hire.
[29:03] Katherine Cooper: Yeah. I actually think, and I never realized this before, there’s a nice parallel to be drawn between what Greg said, a controller versus a CFO, and marketing. I think most people call wanting a fractional CMO when what they really need is a solid marketing agency or team that has direction, has strategy, knows what they’re doing, knows how to go execute. But there is a very real need for the CMO, too, because it’s just like what you said: controller versus the CFO. A great marketing agency can look at what’s working and try to do more of it, right? Or can look at what’s happened in the past: how do we change, how do we tweak something, how do we go get more of the same kind of work?
[29:52] Adam Cooper: I want to add to that. I think the agencies also have the channels that they play in. They understand SEO, and they understand paid advertising, and maybe they understand billboards or magazine placements or something like that, but they don’t necessarily offer everything that could potentially be out there. And the CMO looks at all the channels, like radio, television, billboards, paid sponsorships, and trade shows. A CMO is broader than any agency typically offers. They don’t offer everything.
[30:27] Katherine Cooper: You bring somebody like me in to look at all of it, to know even what all is out there, to look at your business from a more strategic and business side of marketing, not necessarily the tactical side of marketing. And to see what’s in the future. What can you go get? Where can you grow? How do you get there? To make you a roadmap that you can then hand to said doer that you hire, or agency that you hire, and they can go execute and make it happen.
[30:55] Adam Cooper: The other thing that I think a CMO does, because we’ve done this a few times, is we can go commission and get the research done and then interpret that research to set strategy.
[31:07] Katherine Cooper: Yeah,
[31:07] Adam Cooper: We’ve done this recently for a few clients where they didn’t have anybody who could not only source the data but know that it existed.
[31:16] Katherine Cooper: And then as a CMO, you can interpret all that. You can set the strategy based on the actual data that’s available. And now you’re lining out what you need an agency to go do. And marketing is so much science. It really is. It is art, but it’s more science, and it’s more about behavior, and it’s more about understanding that. And this came up in a conversation we recently had. They did a billboard, but it was just done by a marketing person that they had hired to do a billboard. It had no science behind it. It had no human behavior. It was just like, “Oh, it looks nice, so let’s do it.” And then it ended up that the printing was wrong. “It’s cheap. It’s only $2,500 a month.”
[31:50] Jeff Robertson: Well, that’s a really good point, because we have a potential client we’re talking to that hired a fractional CMO
[31:59] Katherine Cooper: Yeah.
[32:00] Jeff Robertson: and was getting kind of a half-ass website out of it.
[32:02] Katherine Cooper: Right?
[32:03] Jeff Robertson: Didn’t know what he was buying, I guess, basically. But that’s the point. If you want to hire somebody to build your website, hire somebody to build your website.
[32:12] Katherine Cooper: Right. Yes. If you don’t even know where you should start first: “Do I need a new website first? Do I need to spend money on ads? Do I need this?” That’s when you hire a CMO to figure out,
[32:21] Jeff Robertson: Right?
[32:22] Katherine Cooper: what is going to make the most bang for your buck, and take it away from my favorite phrase, random acts of marketing, into strategic planned steps that you’re taking in order to get an outcome. I think that applies to COO and CFO, too: random acts of accounting, random acts of operation.
[32:36] Adam Cooper: Well, I think that’s a great thing to think about. The word random probably doesn’t factor into fractional engagements a lot.
[32:48] Katherine Cooper: It shouldn’t.
[32:49] Adam Cooper: Right. It shouldn’t.
[32:49] Jeff Robertson: No, you’re trying to fix the random.
[32:51] Katherine Cooper: That’s what you’re trying to fix. You’re saying stop that.
[32:53] Greg Gorman: Or the engagement itself should not be random. It should be focused on something. What’s the reason? What’s the why behind hiring the fractional person? The randomness of it,
[33:04] Katherine Cooper: Probably, like, “So, what do you want to work on today?” Right? That’s not a great engagement. Exactly. That could be solved in another way. But if you want to hire a fractional executive, there should be some intention behind it. They should be telling you what to do, and not being like, “So, what can I do for you?”
[33:20] Adam Cooper: Yeah. One other thought that comes to my mind: it may have the word fractional in it, but it also has the word executive. So most of the time, in my experience, if you’re hiring a fractional executive, it’s somebody that you want sitting in your leadership meetings. This person is a voice at the table, helping to guide the direction of the company. And even if you’re sitting in the fractional CFO role, you want to be involved in hearing what’s going on in operations, what’s going on in marketing, what’s going on in sales and estimating. They’re part of the team that gets the full picture. They’re brought in for their expertise in one area, but it’s somebody that you basically want sitting in your board meetings every month, that you want to be part of your EOS Rocks meetings, that you want to be part of your strategic planning, your annual strategic planning. They’re filling a vacancy and bringing a knowledge base in to round out your executive team.
[34:14] Katherine Cooper: Yeah. I also think a really important point there, too, is in a world where everybody’s now calling themselves a fractional executive, right? You need to look for people who actually have held executive roles at companies with boards. That’s what’s worth paying the money for. Don’t spend the money on somebody who’s had a marketing role at a company for three years and now has decided to call themselves a CMO for hire, right?
[34:42] Greg Gorman: I think it’s a really great point. Jeff and I both made that same example. I’ve been a CFO for a construction company for a long time. I can be a fractional CFO. I’m not going into that with any anxiety about what is this job, what do they need. I’ve seen, if not all of that, a lot of that, and I can look at the situation as someone who has done it. That’s what you were saying. If you’re going to hire a COO, hire someone with the experience on their resume. Because that experience is what you’re also getting. It’s what you need in the fractional engagement. Look for them the way you would look for a full-time hire that’s an employee, and you’re just buying that skill set part time.
[35:24] Katherine Cooper: Yeah. I think a true fractional executive can show up with, like you said, no anxiety about going into a job. I know I have my switchboard of levers, right, that I have known how to flip, pull, and twist for 15 years. And I know that if I go in, you’re likely going to fit. I’m going to start by doing this one, this one, this one. We’ll see what happens, and we do them again. I know how to do that, and I know how to do it with my eyes closed, and I know how to make it happen quickly.
[35:49] Adam Cooper: And you might not know which lever to pull yet on day one, but by the end of the engagement, you’ve pulled the levers that are required, because you have the experience, right?
[35:58] Katherine Cooper: You also know which questions to ask in the first 30 days to figure out which levers to pull and which dials to start turning. We know the likely suspects.
[36:08] Greg Gorman: We know what good looks like as well. We know what working and functional and healthy looks like. So, we’re quick to be able to spot the areas that need attention.
[36:20] Jeff Robertson: That brings up a really good point. I was talking to somebody yesterday. They’re talking to us because they’d hired a fractional executive advisor, or whatever. I don’t remember what they called it exactly.
[36:35] Adam Cooper: Yeah.
[36:35] Jeff Robertson: That turned out to really only be a sales coach. And they were very disappointed in that. He was helpful, but it wasn’t what they thought. They were getting more broad. They needed more business and operations help. And they said the guy doesn’t have the technical understanding of construction: “He’s helped us with our sales process. That’s been useful, but we ask him other questions and it’s just not there. We need somebody that understands construction from a business side and an operations side, because that’s what we are.”
[37:12] Katherine Cooper: Right?
[37:12] Jeff Robertson: So, it goes back to: hire somebody that has done it before, knows what they’re doing, and it’s not a generic “I’m a business coach. I work with…”
[37:23] Adam Cooper: It’s a very different skill set, very different hire,
[37:27] Adam Cooper: right? And a very different job, too. All things aside, a coach has a job to do, but a fractional executive has a different job to do.
[37:40] Katherine Cooper: I mean, a coach points you in the right direction, and you’re supposed to go do the work. A fractional executive is hired to actually do the work.
[37:48] Greg Gorman: I think that kind of contradicts what we literally just said, though.
[37:51] Katherine Cooper: There’s a little bit of both.
[37:52] Adam Cooper: Well, I mean, if you think about it, business coaches will point you in the right direction. They workshop with you, like your sales process, right? We’ve hired business coaches before, and sales coaches, and all different types of business coaches to help us get better at something, but they weren’t going to go do the work for us. Right. Whereas a fractional CFO, if I’m hiring Greg to be a fractional CFO, there’s outputs, as he said earlier, that he has to deliver.
[38:15] Greg Gorman: Yes.
[38:16] Katherine Cooper: Right. A coach doesn’t deliver the outputs. A coach helps you deliver your own outputs typically.
[38:20] Greg Gorman: That’s right. And while the fractional CFO might not be the one doing the work, someone on your team being overseen by that fractional CFO is doing the work.
[38:31] Adam Cooper: You’re checking the work.
[38:32] Greg Gorman: And I’m checking it and reviewing it and giving advice and looking at the bigger picture. I’m not just out. I haven’t just left and said, “Hey, I already told you what to do. Good luck doing it.”
[38:44] Adam Cooper: We love sports analogies, Jeff. You’re a baseball guy more than the rest of us. When was the last time a batting coach got up there and took any swings at the plate in a real game?
[38:52] Jeff Robertson: Right. Ever.
[38:53] Adam Cooper: He’s there to make sure the players are well prepared to take the swings. That’s what a business coach does, too. He makes you prepared to take all the swings in your game.
[39:03] Jeff Robertson: But a pinch hitter,
[39:04] Katherine Cooper: But a pinch hitter,
[39:05] Jeff Robertson: still not a batting coach.
[39:07] Adam Cooper: That’s the thing.
[39:08] Jeff Robertson: A pinch hitter is not a batting coach.
[39:09] Greg Gorman: Not a pinch batting coach. It’s a pinch hitter.
[39:12] Katherine Cooper: Yeah.
[39:12] Jeff Robertson: That’s the fractional executive.
[39:13] Adam Cooper: A pinch hitter is not a coach, is not a fielder. That’s our tagline. That’s our tagline.
[39:18] Katherine Cooper: There you go.
[39:19] Jeff Robertson: Yeah, they’re not in the field.
[39:20] Adam Cooper: It’s a great place to wrap this one up. All right, that was a fun conversation about fractional executives. I hope you all got something out of that for yourself or your business. Check us out on YouTube, Spotify, Apple, or wherever you get your podcasts. We’ll see you on the next one.